Rare gear.
Second draw.
A small, owner-operated Magic: The Gathering shop. We buy old collections that have been sitting in closets and attics — and we sell curated singles to players and collectors who appreciate them. Honest grading, real photographs, no stock images.
If you have a Magic: The Gathering collection that has been gathering dust for years — yours, a relative's, an estate, a downsized hobby — we are buyers. Especially for cards from the 1990s and early 2000s, Reserved List singles, sealed product, and bulk rares.
We pay competitive rates (typically 70–80% of TCG Mid Price for Reserved List and vintage singles, well above the 50–55% most buylists offer) because our model is to hold quality inventory and resell at retail — not flip cards for a quick margin.
A small shop that knows its inventory.
Listings on TCGplayer and eBay are accurate to condition, photographed on a workbench (not stock images), and priced against the live TCGplayer market. No bulk lots without provenance, no counterfeit risk on key cards.
Reserved List Singles
Mana Vault, Vampiric Tutor, Argothian Enchantress, Time Spiral, and other Reserved List cards from Alpha through Tempest Block. Long-term store-of-value pieces.
Pre-Modern Singles
Cards from 4th Edition, Mirage block, Tempest block, Urza's block, and the early 2000s. Format staples for Old School, Legacy, and Vintage Cube.
Modern Rares & Mythics
Selected cards from Modern, Pioneer, and Commander staples. Tested and graded conservatively before listing.
Honest Grading
Cards inspected against real photos, not pulled from stock images. Edges, surface, and centering called out where relevant. NM, LP, MP, HP — labeled honestly.
Mox Mulligan is operated by a U.S. military veteran with cyber operations experience, and a Magic: The Gathering player since 1995. The shop exists because cards collected for thirty years deserve buyers who appreciate them — and because the secondary market is full of stock-photo listings that hide actual condition.
Every card listed is photographed on a workbench. Conditions are graded honestly. Prices are checked against the live TCGplayer market, not a fantasy multiplier.
Selling a collection, asking a question, or just talking shop.
Email is the fastest way to reach us — typically a 1–2 business day response. For collection inquiries, the sell page has the full pitch and form. For anything else, reach out below.