Cards deserve a second hand.
If you have Magic: The Gathering cards that have been sitting in a closet, garage, attic, or storage unit — we are buyers. Especially for collections from the 1990s and early 2000s, Reserved List singles, sealed product, and estate-scale lots.
We are not a flip-shop, a pawn-shop, or a buylist running 50% offers. We pay competitive rates because our model is to hold quality inventory and resell at retail. Sellers get a fair price; cards find a new home.
Three steps. No surprises.
Email or DM with your cards. A spreadsheet is ideal but not required — set names and rough counts are enough to start. For high-value cards (anything over ~$25), photos help. We'll tell you within a day if the collection is in scope.
We price every card against current TCGplayer market with our offer percentage applied. You get a line-item itemized offer — no "$X for the lot" black box. You see exactly what each card is worth and what we're paying.
Prepaid USPS Priority shipping label for collections over $200. Local handoff in the OKC metro for any size collection. Payment same-day on receipt: Zelle, PayPal Goods & Services, or check.
| Category | Examples | Offer |
|---|---|---|
| Reserved List & vintage singles | Mana Vault, Vampiric Tutor, dual lands, Argothian Enchantress | 70–80% |
| Modern era rares & mythics | Modern format staples, Commander chase rares, recent-set mythics | 55–70% |
| Bulk rares ($1–5 range) | Older sets, off-meta rares, foils with light play wear | $0.10–0.25 each |
| Bulk commons & uncommons | Sorted or unsorted boxes | $5 per 1,000 |
| Sealed product | Booster boxes, Collector Boosters, Commander decks, bundles | 75–85% |
TCG Mid Price = the median market price on TCGplayer at time of offer. We don't lowball with stale prices.
What's in, what's out.
We're a curated shop, not a wholesale operation. We're picky about what we buy because we're picky about what we sell.
Especially interested in
- Collections from the 1990s and early 2000s (Alpha through Onslaught)
- Reserved List cards in any condition
- Sealed product, especially older boxes and Collector Boosters
- Bulk rares and mythics (500+ cards)
- Estate collections and inherited stock
- Foreign-language vintage (especially Italian Legends, FBB)
What we don't buy
- Counterfeits — no exceptions, even at "bulk" prices
- Cards with structural damage (water, fire, mold, glue, ink)
- Single common cards under $1 (not economical)
- Loose Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh, or other TCGs (Magic only for now)
Three options when you have cards to sell.
We're not the only path. Here's the honest comparison.
For local collections, we can meet at a public location, the local game store of your choice, or your home if that's easier. No appraisal fee — we evaluate for free, and you decide whether to accept the offer.